Magna-Tiles vs. Connetix: The Magnetic Tile Showdown
Magna-Tiles has ruled the playroom for more than 20 years, and Connetix, the newer Australian brand, has become its most serious rival. But is the quality really on par? I put the two brands head to head for 3 months to help you choose for your little builder.
Magna-Tiles vs. Connetix: How I Tested Them for 3 Months
For 3 months, I compared them side by side in two homes: one with a 100-piece Magna-Tiles set that had already been played with for 2 years, the other with a brand-new 100-piece Connetix set. I compared magnet strength, see-through colors, thickness, finish, compatibility and cost.
Magna-Tiles Classic 100-Piece Set
Ages 3+
Magna-Tiles or Connetix: The Comparison at a Glance
For busy parents, here's the summary of my 3 months of comparing. The details, criterion by criterion, are right below.
| Criteria | Magna-Tiles | Connetix |
|---|---|---|
| The brand | The American pioneer of magnetic tiles | A newer Australian brand |
| Magnets | Very consistent, hold well in tall builds | Good, a few tiles with slightly off-center magnets in my test |
| Colors | Bright and saturated | Pastel or rainbow, softer |
| Compatibility | Total: the two brands mix without any trouble | |
| Cost (100 pieces) | Changes with sales and seasons | Changes with sales and seasons |
| My advice | A "special" gift, or growing a collection you already have | A first collection, if its price per tile is the lowest on the day you buy |
Magnet Strength: Which Tiles Hold Up in Tall Builds?
Magna-Tiles wins, by a nose. Strong neodymium magnets with a very even pull. Connetix uses comparable magnets, but the way they're sealed in is a little less precise: in my test, about 5% of the tiles had slightly off-center magnets, which made the tallest towers topple sooner.
See-Through Colors and Plastic Quality
A tie. Both use high-quality translucent plastic. Connetix has a small edge on the palette (softer pastel colors, where Magna-Tiles are more saturated). That one comes down to personal taste.
Tile Thickness and Magna-Tiles Compatibility with Connetix
The two brands make tiles of the same thickness and the same sizes, and they click together perfectly. You can mix your collection with no trouble at all, which is a great point if you want to grow it bit by bit.
Magna-Tiles vs. Connetix Cost: How to Compare without Getting Fooled
I'll be honest with you: with magnetic tiles, prices move a lot depending on the season, the set size and the sales (Black Friday, Prime Day, back to school). I've seen each brand come out ahead at different times. So rather than give you a fixed gap that would be wrong next month, here's my method:
- Work out the price per tile: the price of the set divided by the number of pieces. It's the only number that lets you compare a 60-piece set with a 100-piece set.
- Look at what's in the box: big squares and triangles do everything; special pieces (arches, windows) are a bonus.
- Use the compatibility: since the two brands mix, you can add on with whichever one costs less the day you buy.
Always check today's price on Amazon before you order.
Which Magnetic Tile Set to Choose by Age?
At 3, a first set of 30 to 60 pieces is plenty to get started: your child connects tiles, makes flat shapes and builds their first little houses. Between 4 and 6, 100 pieces become really useful: it's the age of towers, garages and rockets, and you run out of big squares fast. After 6, kids love the special pieces and giant group builds. More gift ideas for these ages are in my top 10 gifts for 4-year-olds and my Christmas gift guide by age.
Magnetic Tiles and Safety: The Rule to Know
The magnets are sealed inside the plastic, and that's what makes the tiles safe. The one real risk is a cracked or broken tile that could let a magnet out: if a child swallows more than one small magnet, they can pull together through the intestines, and that's a medical emergency. My careful-bear rule: I throw away any cracked tile without a second thought, I keep the box out of reach of little ones who still put everything in their mouth, and I choose well-known brands that state they meet the US toy safety standard (ASTM F963, which has specific rules for magnets in toys). To decode the label, my guide to US toy safety standards (ASTM F963 and CPSC) explains it all in a few minutes.
Connetix Magnetic Tiles Pastel Creative Pack (120 Pieces)
Ages 3+
Verdict: Magna-Tiles or Connetix for Your Family?
Let's figure it out together. A first collection: the brand with the lowest price per tile on the day you buy (check both). Adding to a Magna-Tiles collection you already have: stick with Magna-Tiles so everything matches. A special gift for your little one: Magna-Tiles, the original brand that still holds its value best.
To discover more building toys, head to my building toys category.